topic Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation in Expedition Discussions

App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

FilipElsen — Wed, 06 Nov 2019 15:08:35 GMT

Hi guys,

I'm using the FW-logs in order to transform the security policies from legacy services towards app-id.

ML logs are onto the system etc.

Analysing rules via: R-click / App-id adoption / retrieve app (slow-fast) works fine.

Fi. Apps Splunk, ms-kms are detected.

When I convert the rule using "App-ID reconciliation / recommended", the service is converted to the detected app-id as-is.

However application dependencies are not taken into account?

fi. Splunk depends on web-browing, sms-kms depends on msrpc-base. This is leading to non-working policies.

I'm using Expedition: 1.1.42 (VM) and 1.1.46.1 (Physical server) both have the same behavior, while I believe this used to work in previous versions?

Thanks a lot,

Filip Elsen

Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

FilipElsen — Thu, 30 Jan 2020 15:15:36 GMT

any news on this?

Am I the only one using or experiencing this issue?

... in the meantime I'm running 1.1.53 with the same issue.

Thanks,

Filip

Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

FilipElsen — Thu, 30 Jan 2020 16:14:49 GMT

A related rule: were app-id adoption is performed

Next: app-id reconciliation:

resulting in following app-id adopted:

But it doesn't take into account dependencies:

As a result the connectivity would break, impact could be generated etc.

Does anyone has this issue?

Thanks,

Filip

Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

dgildelaig — Mon, 03 Feb 2020 08:35:36 GMT

Would it be possible to share the project with fwmigrate at paloaltnetworks dot com via Project->Settings->Export?

I would like to check if the issue is related to the application database being used in your project, what may not be up-to-date and does not know about the dependencies, or if it is actually an issue related to the code that fails to include the dependencies as well.

Let us know via email, and we will update the results here later on

Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

FilipElsen — Mon, 03 Feb 2020 15:29:35 GMT

Hi Didac,

Thanks for the feedback.

Mail sent with all details as requested.

Best regards,

Filip Elsen

Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

FilipElsen.Proximus — Mon, 30 Mar 2020 10:10:25 GMT

Hi, thanks for updating Expedition.

As shown below, the issue is resolved!!

Re: App-id Adoption & App-id Reconciliation

dgildelaig — Wed, 08 Apr 2020 14:20:03 GMT

Thanks for pointing out that the recommended dependencies were missing in the contextual menu