topic Re: Template stack is partial empty??? in Panorama Discussions

Template stack is partial empty???

MarKra — Thu, 10 Nov 2022 12:55:40 GMT

Hello,

I've got strange behaviour of tamplates and template stack in Panorama. When I configure User Identification - PA Network User-ID Agent, tose settings are not visible unde template stack. Setting on this same tab - Server Monitoring and Include/Exclude Networks are visible in template and can be push to devices.

Template, red marked visible changes, in seetings also I set username, password etc.

Template stack. As you see, marked settings are diffrent. I have only one template, it's new installation.

On devices, as you see some settinge are pushed properly, some, marked red as in template stack. They are default and empty (username and password). So result is obviously Access denied :(.

Any idea what is wrong? I'm new in Palo, but this should be logical and simple.

Re: Template stack is partial empty???

PavelK — Thu, 10 Nov 2022 23:51:03 GMT

Hello @MarKra

thank you for posting!

The behavior you described is not expected. I tried the same with PAN-OS 10.1.7 and it worked. All the configuration including "Enable Probing" that was configured in a Template was reflected in a Template Stack.

What PAN-OS version are you running? What happens if you override the setting directly in Template Stack?

Kind Regards

Pavel

Re: Template stack is partial empty???

MarKra — Fri, 11 Nov 2022 10:17:19 GMT

It's

VM Mode	VMware ESXi
Licensed Capacity (devices)	25
Software Version	10.2.3

When I try do changes directly in template stack, they are gone and back to default values. This is happen in section PA Network User-ID Agent, other section - Server Monitoring and Include/Exclude Networks works properly.

Re: Template stack is partial empty???

MarKra — Fri, 11 Nov 2022 14:22:52 GMT

I've already tried make a new template stack and attach to it existing tamplate. Same effect, nothing change.

Re: Template stack is partial empty???

PavelK — Sun, 13 Nov 2022 23:16:05 GMT

Thank you for reply @MarKra

I went through release notes for 10.2.3, but could not find any related bug. From screen shots you provided, the configuration looks correct. I would advice to open a TAC ticket to confirm this is a bug.

Kind Regards

Pavel

Re: Template stack is partial empty???

TorokAdam — Mon, 28 Nov 2022 14:21:53 GMT

I've first noticed this bug on PAN-OS 10.2.2. I think it's a GUI only bug, if you check the settings from cli configure, you will see that the settings gets populated:

"show user-id-collector setting"

I would say that the access denied comes from another problem (most of the time windows firewall in my cases)

Re: Template stack is partial empty???

JimMcGrady — Fri, 04 Aug 2023 05:06:57 GMT

Similarly i have noticed that the gui options in Panorama under device - user identification do not match the options under the same menu on the gateway. I'm running panorama PanOS 10.1 and gateway PanOS 9.1.