topic Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI in Panorama Discussions

Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

weezy — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 03:06:43 GMT

Needing your help I'm newbie on Palo alto . We have a Panorama on one of our sites this is PA 200 before I'm seeing the primary on panorama but not its not. Although I can access it via SSH and use the CLI but when I run the show running sync-to-panorama command it was not on list. This panoramas are old ones and slow. The mgmt and policies are allowed. We have a fail over testing within the next 2 weeks for audit.

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

PavelK — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 03:24:35 GMT

Hello @weezy

to troubleshoot Firewall connection / registration issue with Panorama, could you check this KB: Troubleshooting Panorama Connectivity. If the issue is not resolved after following steps in KB, could you provide output from below commands from Firewall:

show panorama-status
show netstat all yes numeric-hosts yes numeric-ports yes

Also, could you check content of below file from CLI?

less mp-log ms.log

Kind Regards

Pavel

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

weezy — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 03:39:16 GMT

Hi when I check the status it says HA disconnected

Connected : no
HA state : disconnected

We have our senior engr on Palo alto working on this and I don't have an update yet as still waiting for his reply. I know as well that this old Palo alto 200 are lots of issues before I came in. But I notice before HA is connected and I'm seeing the primary on Panorama

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

weezy — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 03:43:24 GMT

Hi Pavel,

When I do the sh netstat command I got this message

Server error : op command for client dagger timed out as client is not available

Also when doing a fail over test on palo alto the best way is shutting down the primary device? or suspend HA and shut the interface of primary PA facing internet

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

PavelK — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 04:22:18 GMT

Hello @weezy

thank you for reply.

The error you reported seems related to this KB: CLI command 'show netstat listening yes' fails intermittently.

Regarding HA Failover, no need to reboot Firewall nor shut down interface. You can trigger a failover by suspending Firewall:

CLI: request high-availability state suspend
GUI: Device > High Availability > Operational Commands - click Suspend local device

Kind Regards

Pavel

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

weezy — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 04:57:34 GMT

Hi Pavel,

I tried to do it on LAB suspending the HA will lead only to split brain. from active passive setup. It will become active active as they are both forwarding the same data and it might cause a problem. So was it better to shut the primary firewall instead?

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

PavelK — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 05:44:51 GMT

Hello @weezy

thank you for reply.

Regarding split brain, could you confirm whether you enabled HA1 backup link? This is a mitigation against split brain scenario.

High-Availability - Split Brain

DotW: What is Peer-Split-Brain?

If you have no other choice, then I would shut down / disconnect data plane interfaces (In this case you can still access Firewall by management port) or power Firewall off.

Kind Regards

Pavel

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

weezy — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 05:55:14 GMT

Hi Pavel,

Unfortunately we don't have a back up MGMT ip configured and I don't want to add because our PA 200 is so slow it has a lot of weird issues. So what I will do is disconnect the cables

Re: Primary palo alto 220 missing on panorama but I can access it via CLI

weezy — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 06:08:14 GMT

Also I see some post on group that the heartbackup will help on preventing split brain. Please see below the post that I see on PA live community

Split brain conditions can be prevented by configuring an HA1 Backup link and/or enabling Heartbeat Backup.

https://live.paloaltonetworks.com/t5/general-topics/what-is-peer-split-brain/m-p/19825#U19825