topic Re: Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error in Automation/API Discussions

Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error

${userLoginName} — Mon, 18 Nov 2013 19:17:10 GMT

Hi all.

Thanks to excellent guidance found elsewhere (using panxapi to update a custom-url-category profile from a file), I was successfully and reliably able to add and update custom URL categories via the API. Recently something changed that caused my scripts to fail. Whenever the API is used to update a custom URL category, it returns "Edit breaks config validity". This happens when updates are made to existing ones or when new lists are added. I can import the file via the GUI or do the same thing via the command line, and they work fine. I've removed the categories, saved, committed, everything I can think of, but the API always returns the same result. I cannot think of a change recently that would have caused this to happen.

Below is a transcript of a config attempt I just made:

eric@leela:~$ cat testurl.xml

<list><member>www.foobarbaz.com</member></list>

eric@leela:~$ ~/PAN-perl-20120107/bin/panxapi -t panorama -e testurl.xml "/config/shared/profiles/custom-url-category/entry[@name='BrandNewList']/list"

edit: Edit breaks config validity status="error" code="12"

eric@leela:~$

eric@leela:~$ ssh panapi@panorama

Password:

Welcome panapi.

panapi@Panorama> configure

Entering configuration mode

[edit]

panapi@Panorama# set shared profiles custom-url-category BrandNewList list [ www.foobarbaz.com ]

[edit]

panapi@Panorama# commit

.99%.......100%

Configuration committed successfully

[edit]

panapi@Panorama#

Thanks for your help.

Eric

Re: Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error

gwesson — Mon, 18 Nov 2013 19:36:41 GMT

The API is a community-supported function, and you may have better luck at the DevCenter, where scripts and such are posted:

https://live.paloaltonetworks.com/community/devcenter

You can always take a look at your config from a time you knew the script was working under Device > Config Audit, and selecting the current config and comparing it to one at a time the script worked. Maybe a change to something on the firewall is preventing the script from running correctly.

Hope this helps,

Greg

Re: Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error

${userLoginName} — Mon, 18 Nov 2013 20:09:32 GMT

Yes, I have done a config audit and nothing stands out at this time.

Re: Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error

jslabaugh1 — Wed, 22 Oct 2014 15:36:10 GMT

Were you ever able to figure this out?

Re: Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error

${userLoginName} — Mon, 03 Nov 2014 18:12:28 GMT

I did... I think it turned out to be a bug in my script, but I can't remember exactly what it was.

Re: Custom URL Category update via API returns "Edit breaks config validity" error

ksteves1 — Tue, 04 Nov 2014 04:26:58 GMT

I think the problem is '-e testurl.xml' should be '-e ./testurl.xml'; otherwise it is not read as a file.

using the Python panxapi.py you could specify '-e testurl.xml'