Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time

Metgatz — Thu, 13 Oct 2022 19:17:45 GMT

Hello good afternoon, thank you very much for your usual collaboration.

I have a question, regarding HA Links monitor timers.

When one has configured a track or HA Link Monitor, some interfaces, checking the HA timers, the one that corresponds is: Monitor Fail Hold Up Time (ms). It is both in recommended as in aggressive by default this in "0 ms", therefore it means that to the smallest detail, to the smallest Flap at the level of interfaces that detects the Palo Alto, this will immediately trigger a Fail Over, that is to say immediately since it waits according to the Monitor Fail Hold Up Time (ms) 0 Milliseconds.

Reviewing the doc indicates:

Monitor Fail Hold Up Time (ms):
Interval during which the firewall will remain active following a path monitor or link monitor failure. This setting is recommended to avoid an HA failover due to the occasional flapping of neighboring devices.

https://docs.paloaltonetworks.com/pan-os/9-1/pan-os-admin/high-availability/ha-concepts/ha-timers

If we take it to a scenario where for example there may be an occasional flap on the interface of the switch where it is connected, as the doc indicates, a slight flap, the firewall high stick will detect the drop and trigger a fail over, so here what would be the recommendation ???? Leave it at 0 ms ? or set it to 1000 ms ( 1 second ) or 1500 ( 1.5 seconds ) ? so that the Palo Alto waits and validates that there is no longer a failure in that Link and therefore the Link Monitor will not trigger the Fail over since it waited 1 or 2 seconds approx since it was only a flap, not a real fall of the interface, a physical failure of the link or a failure of the entire switch.

As always thank you very much for your support

I remain attentive

Best regards

Re: Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time

kiwi — Mon, 17 Oct 2022 11:05:01 GMT

Hi @Metgatz ,

I would recommend to leave the Monitor Fail Hold Up Time set to 0 ms and configure an HA Path Monitor value to determine a failed path. For links that exhibit periodic flapping you can configure the path monitoring value for a longer duration.

Hope this helps,

-Kiwi.

Re: Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time

mR00t_s5 — Thu, 19 Oct 2023 16:01:04 GMT

Hi! I have the same doubt and I found this post. Did you find any other information about this issue? It seems like it's not entirely clear on the documents. You can set up Ping Count and Ping Interval for a Monitored Path but not for a Link. Could you share how you solved this? Thanks!

topic Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time in General Topics

Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time

Re: Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time

Re: Palo alto network HA link monitor failover Monitor Fail Hold Up Time