Pan OS 5.0

edwinchristopher — Thu, 05 Sep 2013 05:44:59 GMT

i have set up Palo Alto to send logs to syslog server.

Yesterday i have seen something unusual in THREAT,url log?

The length of the URL is 1044 bytes but in the Palo Alto log i can see some of the bytes is truncated?

Original URL:

http://s.youtube.com/api/stats/watchtime?feature=fvwrel&rt=6.827&cos=Windows&cosver=6.1&len=300&cpn=xilIxgDpN0ymnVDt&ns=yt&et=1.666,

31.032&plid=AATlflqGqxQyiWvv&st=0,27.009&fs=0&cbrver=9.0&hl=en_US&cr=US&ei=4iEmUoDlC8XDlwfK6oHwAg&docid=lHFg0T9SYtI&state=playing&cver=as3&

c=WEB&cbr=IE&lact=7257&ver=2&ldpj=-24&fmt=134&cmt=31.112&rtn=16&rti=6&el=detailpage&idpj=-4&fexp=917000,909703,910207,923302,914072,

916623,930901,929117,929121,929906,929907,929922,929127,929129,929131,929930,936403,925726,925720,925722,925718,929917,906945,929933,

920302,906842,913428,920605,919811,913563,904830,919373,930803,904122,932211,938701,936308,909549,912711,904494,904497,939903,900375,

934507,936312,906001,930000,5757575757,474774747,474774747747,488484838399389,784848484884848,44444444,4774747747477474747474747,

888888888888888888,99999999999999999999,111111111111111111111111111111111,2222222222222222222222222,8948848488348934838989389389389389,

111111111111111111,55555555555555345345345,666666666666666666666,777777777777,99999999999999999999,66666666,111

Length of the original URL is 1044 bytes.

Log Line :

Sep 04 21:40:13 xx.xx.xx.xx Sep 4 21:38:24 1,2013/09/04 21:38:24,007000001148,THREAT,url,1,2013/09/04 21:38:23,xx.xx.xx.xx,xx.xx.xx.xx,xx.xx.xx.xx,xx.xx.xx.xx,Test,,,http-proxy,vsys1,Trust,Untrust,ethernetx/y,ethernetx/z,Log Forwarding,2013/09/04 21:38:23,40789,1,63718,3128,0,0,0x0,tcp,block-url,"s.youtube.com/api/stats/watchtime?feature=fvwrel&rt=6.827&cos=Windows&cosver=6.1&len=300&cpn=xilIxgDpN0ymnVDt&ns=yt&et=1.666,31.032&plid=AATlflqGqxQyiWvv&st=0,27.009&fs=0&cbrver=9.0&hl=en_US&cr=US&ei=4iEmUoDlC8XDlwfK6oHwAg&docid=lHFg0T9SYtI&state=playing&cver=as3&c=WEB&cbr=IE&lact=7257&ver=2&ldpj=-24&fmt=134&cmt=31.112&rtn=16&rti=6&el=detailpage&idpj=-4&fexp=917000,909703,910207,923302,914072,916623,930901,929117,929121,929906,929907,929922,929127,929129,929131,929930,936403,925726,925720,925722,925718,929917,906945,929933,920302,906842,913428,920605,919811,913563,904830,919373,930803,904122,932211,938701,936308,909549,912711,904494,904497,939903,900375,934507,936312,906001,930000,5757575757,474774747,474774747747,488484838399389,784848484884848,44444444,4774747747477474747474747,888888888888888888,99999999999999999999,111111111111111111111111111111111,2222222222222222222222222,8948848488348934838989389389389389,111111111111111111,55555555555555345345345,666666666666666666666,777777777777,9999999999999999999",(9999),streaming-media,informational,client-to-server,419,0x0,192.168.0.0-192.168.255.255,192.168.0.0-192.168.255.255,0,,

if you see the url highlighted in red in the log line only 1023 bytes is shown and the rest of the bytes highlighted in pink in original URL is missing?

Is Palo Alto truncates the URL if it is longer than 1024 bytes?

If it is truncating the URL then some thing is wrong because it should truncate the message not the the URL in between!!!!!

Re: Pan OS 5.0

sraghunandan — Thu, 05 Sep 2013 06:17:49 GMT

If your are using PAN-DB then there is an imposed limit of 1024 characters for the length of a URL, which includes both the host and the path. PAN-OS will normalize the URL by removing the following:

Tab (0x09), CR (0x0d), LF (0x0a) characters from the URL
Fragment parameters (e.g. www.google.com/#frag is shortened to www.google.com/)
Remove hex encodings (e.g. %43 or \x43 would change to '+')
Query parameters (www.google.com/search?q=abcd+xyz) becomes (www.google.com/search)

After normalization, length of the final URL is checked. If it length is greater than the allowed 1024, the URL is truncated and the first 1024 characters is sent to the MP for a query.

Re: Pan OS 5.0

mikand — Thu, 05 Sep 2013 22:48:54 GMT

Also according to RFC 3164 (RFC regarding syslog) the total length of the (syslog) packet MUST be 1024 bytes or less.

http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3164.txt

I dont know if PA puts this limit on syslog packets being sent out of the box but there is a great risk that the syslog server who accepts the log from your PA might cut and throw away any data thats beyond 1024 bytes.

Speaking of which... if PA do cut any data beyond the 1024 bytes marker - will the same occur on custom logs sent as CEF to Arcsight installation or such?

topic Pan OS 5.0 in General Topics

Pan OS 5.0

Re: Pan OS 5.0

Re: Pan OS 5.0