topic Re: FTP slow through PA-500 in General Topics

FTP slow through PA-500

lhank — Fri, 12 Nov 2010 10:29:41 GMT

Hi,

We have our PA-500 set up as follows:

Ports 1 & 2 as VWire connected to our firewall with AV and malware scanning

Ports 3 & 4 as L3 for our user traffic, scanning AV and Malware and URL filtering

When a user uses FTP to send files to servers on our DMZ through the L3 connection they are only getting 2-300kbp/s throughput, but if they use the VWire, the transfer rate is 20 Mb/s upwards to our DMZ.

We have tried several FTP clients, and also added specific FTP policy rules with destination set etc, with no scanning of traffic, but it does not make any difference.

Is there a way to increase this specific FTP traffic to the DMZ ?

Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks

Lee Hancock

Re: FTP slow through PA-500

Tomoyuki — Fri, 12 Nov 2010 13:48:20 GMT

Hi Lee, and PA Support Team,

I have additional informations.

I tested FTP through put with AntiVirus.

Device : PA-4060

- OS : 3.1.2

- Application : 217-785

- AntiVirus : 341-427

- InterfaceMode : L3

Server : Windows2008R2

Client : Windows7 64bit

- FTP client : FileZilla3.3.0

Through Put

- no AV FTP get : 465.1Mbps

- AV FTP get : 452.0Mbps

- no AV FTP put : 500.0Mbps

- AV FTP put : 62.8Mbps

It seems the same issue with the Lee's one.

I'll get a tech-support and open a new case.

Thank you,

Tomoyuki Komure

Re: FTP slow through PA-500

djmac — Fri, 12 Nov 2010 19:11:11 GMT

Most of the issues ive had with slow large file downloads (ftp, update, etc etc) have been simple port speed / duplex miss-matches

This seems to an issue when in Vwire mode!

Re: FTP slow through PA-500

lhank — Mon, 15 Nov 2010 11:50:59 GMT

Hi djmac,

I didn't think of that!!, I've gone through and checked the connections and it was connecting to our DMZ at only 100Mb.

I've now made changes to the networking side, etc, and set the Palo Alto connections to 1000 Mb/s Full Duplex.

I've tested FTP again and the transfer rate through the Palo Alto L3 connection is now 20-40 Mb/s, which is satifactory for the relevant users, although to a server still at 100 Mb connection in our DMZ (can't replace DMZ switches for full Gigabit yet !!) it's FTP transfer was 3-8 Mb/s.

I'm going to do some more testing through the VWire connection, but would be interested in others advice about this.

Lee

Re: FTP slow through PA-500

djmac — Tue, 16 Nov 2010 17:06:38 GMT

Funny thing is we had a similar thing happen with MSUPDATES and the Palo software update. It seems the mismatch only becomes an issue when the link is loaded. We also find this happen more with HP switches.