topic Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment? in General Topics

Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

_slv_ — Fri, 05 Oct 2012 14:52:55 GMT

Hello

I find that in PAN 4.1.8 is new feature:

"User/Group-based Portal Configurations – The GlobalProtect Portal now supports multiple agent configurations on a per-user or user-group basis within one portal configuration."

I know that its fresh ... but I need this feature.

Is it safe to put it on my PA-200 at the moment?

With regards

SLawek

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

sdurga — Fri, 05 Oct 2012 16:13:02 GMT

So far one issue that I have seen with many users is documented in this doc .https://live.paloaltonetworks.com/docs/DOC-3860

and its not a major issue. However, you can open a ticket with support so that we can have a look at your current configuration and based on that we can let you know the current issues on 4.1.8 that your might run into.

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

ExclusiveNetworksGermany — Mon, 08 Oct 2012 11:22:55 GMT

Hi Slv,

i am a little bit confused

PAN 4.1.8 is only a Bugfix Release with no new Features.

There is currently no other Major Release than 4.1.x available for PA 200

So this Feature should already work on your Device.

Next Major Release with new Features will be 5.0.x (no i don't know when it will be released 😉 )

It is (mostly) recommended to use the latest Bugfix Release.

Regards

Marco

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

_slv_ — Tue, 09 Oct 2012 07:00:19 GMT

Thats good news for me, in near future I will upgrade my device and I let you know about results.

With Regards

SLawek

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

_slv_ — Thu, 11 Oct 2012 07:30:20 GMT

Hello

Device upgraded sucessfully. But upgrade process take a lot of time (much longer than progress bar on web browser shows), I think that was more than 10minuts.

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

ppatel — Thu, 11 Oct 2012 07:46:15 GMT

Hi,

The reboot of the device followed by the auto-commit also depends upon the Hardware Platform.

For PA 500 and 2000 series, we have seen instances where auto commit takes a while to complete as compared to 5000 series

Regards

Parth

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

notes01 — Thu, 18 Oct 2012 12:47:57 GMT

4.1.8 looks a lot better for production than 4.1.6 ever was. I now regard 4.1.6 as "toxic"! That said, I've only upgraded Panorama to 4.1.8 so far, with the PANs still running 4.1.6, but already a couple of really annoying bugs are fixed in Panorama and at least one weird and mysterious failure on the PANs seems to be fixed simply by uploading policy from it.

In our 4.1.6 setup, it seems almost certain now that adding or changing any rule might have impact on any other rule in any zone, or on Layer 2 functionality. Completely random. After going to 4.1.6, we suffered gradual lost or mangled functionality in H.245, H.323, ARP caching, db2... these are just the ones I've scratched my head over while the logs tell me all's well and the users scream blue murder. I would like to nominate 4.1.6 as a candidate for withdrawal, tbh.

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

notes01 — Wed, 24 Oct 2012 14:08:45 GMT

Just to add a little bit more: I updated our 5020s from 4.1.6 through 4.1.7 to 4.1.8 on Tuesday morning (took 17 minutes each) and everything is running sweetly with no user complaints so far. Seems to me that UTM is working far more efficiently - or reporting far more - in 4.1.8, for which I am grateful.

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

dieter_b — Thu, 25 Oct 2012 07:52:10 GMT

How about commit times ? Are they any better ?

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

notes01 — Thu, 25 Oct 2012 09:30:13 GMT

No change in commit times, although with the 5000 series they have never been shabby anyway. About 40 seconds? Sounds about right.

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

mikand — Thu, 25 Oct 2012 10:31:38 GMT

Perhaps thats why the 3000-series are coming in order to replace the 2000-series regarding commit times (in reality more ram and faster mgmtplane cpu to lower the commit times from 20 minutes or more to sub minute)?

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

JRussell — Thu, 25 Oct 2012 10:59:45 GMT

I am running a 2020 series box but I have not noticed any notice to the commit times. It's still as slow as ever. Although reading mikand's comment of it taking 20 minutes to commit then perhaps my commit time of up to 10 minutes at times is not that bad?

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

notes01 — Thu, 25 Oct 2012 11:39:14 GMT

I was told, on my Palo course earlier this year, that the management CPU on the 5000s is basically Intel quad-core - possibly the same on the 4000s - but on the smaller devices I'm not sure. 10-20 minutes is something I cannot imagine.... bet you guys take pains to get changes right first time, every time. You have my sympathy, not that it helps.

Re: Is it PAN 4.1.8 ready for production environment?

dieter_b — Wed, 14 Nov 2012 08:44:53 GMT

I have it running since about 2 weeks. To my feeling, the GUI and commit times are somewhat better.