RuntimeBroker.exe as Parent Process

cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome Idira to LIVEcommunity!

Our community just got stronger! Explore new identity security resources, connect with experts, and discover more ways to learn and collaborate.

Meet Idira

RuntimeBroker.exe as Parent Process

L2 Linker

I'm submitting a case on this, but I wanted to see if anyone in the community has had an issue with RuntimeBroker.exe being the parent process for application launches?

 

If you launch a UWP/Windows Store/Metro app by most methods, the parent process is an on-the-fly instance of RuntimeBroker.exe

 

You can see this by launching something like SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe

2023.10.17 10:06:39 PID:6448 TID:13588 CvfProcessStartRights::PROCSTART: pid=27088, parent=24028, exe=[C:\Windows\System32\SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe], cmdLine=["C:\Windows\System32\SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe" ], policyId=64646, action=3 (ELEVATE), policyName=[App - AppDev Baseline - Elevate]

The parent, 27088, is not Explorer as you'd expect, but a transitory instance of RuntimeBroker.exe

 

Why is this an issue?

 

In my case, I'm moving "admins" to role based rights. I've got a group with a "backstop" allowing all apps and their children (an improvement from their un-logged, no-justification free-for-all) while we build them an actual role-based group and filter their wheat from their chaff.

2023.10.16 15:10:40 PID:6448 TID:14032 CvfProcessStartRights::PROCSTART: pid=22968, parent=17464, exe=[C:\Windows\System32\SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe], cmdLine=["C:\Windows\System32\SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe" ], policyId=45306, action=4 (ELEVATE_ON_DEMAND) inherited from parent action 1 (NORMAL_RUN), policyName=[Backstop - Admin - delg-epm-wkst-admin]

When the user launches SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe, Windows passes "SPA" to RuntimeBroker.exe - but "RB" is already a running process, so instead of EPM evaluating the merits of SPA based on any rule that might match it, it evaluates it as a child of RB.

 

So my higher-priority team-based rule to allow "SPA" to elevate automatically for teams and correctly categorizing their activity instead of hitting their backstop never triggers.

 

Should EPM "ignore" RuntimeBroker as a parent?

 

To work around this, I'm currently testing an "Allow" rule for RuntimeBroker.exe with a priority just ahead of my backstop rules with children disabled.

 

Simplified, I now have:

 

  • 330: Elevate SystemPropertiesAdanced.exe for De-Admin group.
  • 620: Allow RuntimeBroker.exe as "Allow" - no children.
  • 640: Elevate as Necessary for All Applications for Former-Admins group.

 

But I'm fearful about the consequences of "Allow"-ing RuntimeBroker.exe

 

I'll update this if I hear anything from my incident that isn't echoed here.

 

If anyone's encountered this, please share 🙂

 

[As a small note, if you launch SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe from the start/search menu, it uses RuntimeBroker as the parent. If you launch SystemPropertiesAdvanced.exe from Explorer, it uses Explorer.exe as the parent.]

 

 

 

1 accepted solution

Accepted Solutions

Hi @Matthew Stenger​,

 

Our support team met with you to explain the appropriate policy configurations better, and the support case is closed.

 

The Runtimebroker.exe is a unique system process. The user does not create it. If you tell Windows to launch a specific type of program, Windows instead uses an intermediate program – Runtimebroker.exe – to launch your requested application.

 

Please reopen the support ticket if there are more questions or issues with the suggested solution given by our support team.

 

Thanks,

Tamir

View solution in original post

3 REPLIES 3

L4 Transporter

Hi @Matthew Stenger​ 

 

Is there any progress with the issue?

In case you got a resolution for support, could you kindly share how to resolve this issue?

 

Thanks,

Niv

Thanks for asking.

 

Yes, and also no.

 

I'm still using this ruleset.

 

  • 330: Elevate SystemPropertiesAdanced.exe for De-Admin group.
  • 620: Allow RuntimeBroker.exe as "Allow" - no children.
  • 640: Elevate as Necessary for All Applications for Former-Admins group.

 

Our 640 rule is granting "admin" to people in an AD group after all team rules.

The 330 will not trigger without the 620 rule.

The 620 rule which specifically enumerates RuntimeBroker.exe causes it to NOT be seen as a child of the 640 rule.

 

The 620 and 640 groups are targeted to my "admis."

The 330 rule is targeted to the people I'm transitioning out of admin - but who are still members as we organize them.

 

RuntimeBroker.exe doesn't seem to mind, and about 300 people have this rule.

 

I believe I can promote this rule to a higher level and to all users, but it's only required to be before any "all" rule that allows children.

 

I'm still VERY MUCH under the opinion that EPM itself should ignore RuntimeBroker.exe as a parent process - like Eplorer - and I've been promised a meeting on the subject, but it hasn't yet materialized.

 

Here's my very simple rule and application group.

 

I hope this helps, but support has been almost entirely hands-off. 😒

 

 

Field_Content_versions_oct20__068Ht00000T66cvIAB.pngField_Content_versions_oct20__068Ht00000T66emIAB.png 

Hi @Matthew Stenger​,

 

Our support team met with you to explain the appropriate policy configurations better, and the support case is closed.

 

The Runtimebroker.exe is a unique system process. The user does not create it. If you tell Windows to launch a specific type of program, Windows instead uses an intermediate program – Runtimebroker.exe – to launch your requested application.

 

Please reopen the support ticket if there are more questions or issues with the suggested solution given by our support team.

 

Thanks,

Tamir

  • 1 accepted solution
  • 15 Views
  • 3 replies
  • 0 Likes
Like what you see?

Show your appreciation!

Click Like if a post is helpful to you or if you just want to show your support.

Click Accept as Solution to acknowledge that the answer to your question has been provided.

The button appears next to the replies on topics you’ve started. The member who gave the solution and all future visitors to this topic will appreciate it!

These simple actions take just seconds of your time, but go a long way in showing appreciation for community members and the LIVEcommunity as a whole!

The LIVEcommunity thanks you for your participation!