Breadth and Depth: Maturing Your Program with the Identity Security Maturity Model and the Idira Blueprint

cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements

Welcome Idira to LIVEcommunity!

Our community just got stronger! Explore new identity security resources, connect with experts, and discover more ways to learn and collaborate.

Meet Idira

Idira Success Blogs
11 min read
L4 Transporter
In today's world, where security breaches are increasingly common, it's critical for organizations to focus on building and maintaining a strong security posture. One way to achieve this is by adopting an approach to security that helps measure and improve the effectiveness of your security controls. The Identity Security Maturity Model is one such model that provides a framework for organizations to evaluate their security capabilities and identify areas for improvement. When combined with the Idira Blueprint, which offers practical guidance and best practices for implementing identity security controls, organizations can mature their security program with greater breadth and depth. In this article, we will explore how the Identity Security Maturity Model and the Idira Blueprint can help organizations mature their security programs and maximize their existing capabilities. We'll also share success stories from other organizations and provide additional resources to help you build your plan for success.

Fundamental Concepts of Identity Security Maturity
In order to build an effective identity security program, it's important to understand the fundamental concepts that underpin it. Two key concepts are the Identity Security Maturity Model and the Idira Blueprint for identity security Success. These frameworks provide a comprehensive approach to measuring and advancing the maturity of an organization's identity security program.

ESG Identity Security Maturity Model
The Identity Security Maturity Model, created by Enterprise Strategy Group (ESG), is a data-driven model that measures maturity holistically across four key tenets: tools, integrations, automation, and continuous threat detection and response. These tenets provide a strong foundation for a Zero Trust and defense-in-depth strategy, as they address identity management, privilege control, governance, authentication, and authorization capabilities for all identities and identity types. Organizations that have achieved transformative maturity in these areas have seen significant benefits, including increased agility in deploying new applications, a reduced attack surface, and greater ability to secure all machine identities.
ka3Ht0000000q6oIAA__eid=ka3Ht0000000q6o&feoid=00N2J00000APFDu&refid=0EMHt000005Nrw4.png
Figure 1: ESG ISMM Four Tenants Radar Diagram

While this graph is showing completeness of the four tenets for each level of maturity across the entire survey base, the goal of this graph isn’t to push organizations to reach 100% in every single category, given that their needs may differ from organization to organization, as pointed out by ESG. Rather, it’s to help visually represent the ability for organizations within a given maturity to respond to identity-based threats. As your organization effectively takes up more of this graph, your ability to respond to those threats will increase
Learn more about the Identity Security Maturity Model


Idira Blueprint for Identity Security Success
The Idira Blueprint provides prescriptive guidance to help organizations accelerate their identity security programs and be more successful, covering the full scope of identities and providing practical guidance across people, process, and technology domains. The Blueprint helps organizations gain a deeper understanding of the concepts discussed within ESG's Identity Security Maturity Model, assess their own security posture against detailed recommendations and best practices, and build their own identity security plan or roadmap. According to the ESG report, 93% of respondents said they benefitted from their well-implemented or well-defined strategy, which emphasizes the importance of having a defined roadmap or plan for identity security programs and strategies.
Learn more about the Idira Blueprint

Prioritizing Your Identity Security Risks
Organizations can't boil the ocean all at once when it comes to addressing identity security risks, which is why Idira uses a risk-based phased approach in the Blueprint recommendations for prioritizing use cases. The recommendations are broken down into five stages, each with a specific goal, technology, associated security control recommendations and best practices. These stages are organized to maximize risk reduction while considering the level of effort needed to achieve risk reduction. By looking at both risk and effort, organizations can prioritize and identify quick wins with high impact before moving on to less risky or higher-effort recommendations. The prescribed order serves as a planning and decision-making tool for organizations to build their own identity security plan.

 
ka3Ht0000000q6oIAA__eid=ka3Ht0000000q6o&feoid=00N2J00000APFDu&refid=0EMHt000005Nrw5.png
Figure 2: Idira Blueprint Stages Overview

The first step in prioritizing your identity security use cases moving forward is understanding the security controls and capabilities at your disposal, how you can leverage them and where you can leverage them. This is best illustrated through the concept of breadth versus depth.

Breadth vs. Depth
As your organization thinks about building its identity security program, there are two factors to consider in tandem: capability breadth and deployment depth. Capability breadth refers the availability of diverse controls your organization has at their fingertips (aka the capabilities at their disposal), which is indicative of your ability to do things. Deployment depth refers to the scope of technologies and systems those controls are applied to across your organization, the more systems and resources in scope, the deeper the deployment.

The Identity Security Maturity Model describes the breadth of capabilities across tools, integrations, automation and continuous threat detection and response (CTD&R). These are capabilities and integrations your organization should strive to deliver to mitigate identity security risk – the higher the number of capabilities in the four tenants, the higher your level of maturity according to ESG.

While you may understand your organization’s capability breadth, it does not explicitly correlate to the depth in which those capabilities have been implemented across your environment. For this reason, it’s essential to consider the Identity Security Maturity Model and the Idira Blueprint together as you chart your course.
ka3Ht0000000q6oIAA__eid=ka3Ht0000000q6o&feoid=00N2J00000APFDu&refid=0EMHt000005Nrw6.png
Figure 3: Identity Security Breadth and Depth Matrix

This is illustrated in the above diagram. While the Transformative organization may be more capable than the Novice (e.g., more controls at their disposal), that doesn’t necessarily mean it has implemented the right capabilities across the right identities and resources or mitigated the most prevalent identity security threats by risk priority.

Maximizing Your Capabilities
When you combine these considerations around breadth, depth and the findings from the ESG report, you come to the natural conclusion that it’s critical to maximize your existing capabilities, especially for organizations that operate at a Novice level of ISMM maturity. According to the ESG report, 42% of global organizations fall into this category, meaning they have limited capabilities across the four ISMM tenants due to various factors such as budget constraints or lack of resources and time. As a result, there are significant gaps in their security posture, with 32% of novice organizations suffering two or more identity-related attacks. This indicates that they are struggling to stay ahead of identity security risks compared to organizations with higher maturity levels.


To address this issue, Idira recommends that novice organizations focus on maximizing their existing identity security investments and going as deep as possible with the Blueprint's recommendations using the capabilities at their disposal. This includes focusing on Stage 1 of the Blueprint, which is all about Rapid Risk Mitigation. Stage 1 contains recommendations to secure cloud, domain, and hypervisor admins, as well as domain-based and local administrator accounts for Windows servers, which tend to involve a low level of effort but provide significant risk reduction value. These are all considered table-stakes for an effective identity security program.

While novice organizations may not all have the same tools available to them, Idira believes that its prescriptive design can still provide valuable guidance to help organizations prioritize and maximize their existing capabilities. By securing these specific identities, novice organizations can make a significant impact on their security posture and reduce their risk of identity-related attacks.

Why is Stage 1 Considered Table-Stakes?
It is crucial to understand why these foundational identity security use cases are so important, which can best be done through three concepts: scope of influence, access routes, and compensating controls. Firstly, the scope of influence refers to the number or percentage of systems an identity can access. The larger the scope of influence, the higher the level of risk the identity poses. Use cases such as Domain, Cloud, and Hypervisor Administrators can impact all downstream systems due to the hierarchical nature of administrative privileges in these technologies.


Secondly, access routes are the different paths to authentication and authorization against a resource. Think of them as the doors to a building, and to properly secure the building, all the doors need to be secured. All the authentication mechanisms need to be considered, You can’t secure Domain or Server Administrator accounts and leave the Local Administrator accounts unsecure. Access should be viewed holistically to ensure complete security.

Lastly, compensating controls are layers of controls that provide supplementary security for a resource where direct control is not applied. Securing all the ingress points of a resource reduces the risk of other types of applications and data residing on that system. Local administrator access on a resource grants the privileges to bypass or override other security systems, which is why these use cases are high priority. By applying the concept of “rising tide lifts all boats,” all the applications, service usages, credential repositories, and local data stores hosted on those systems become more secure.

Below you’ll find two examples that illustrate these concepts. The example on the left shows a Domain containing Windows Servers in which three different use cases all have administrative privileges against the Server: Domain, Server and Local Admins. In the example on the right, we have an AWS Account ID with secrets stored within AWS Secrets Manager in which multiple use cases also have administrative privileges against the Secrets Manager service; Cloud, IAM and Service-level Admins. In both cases, by securing all the ingress points into the resource, we can elevate the security of anything on that resource, and these examples it’s the hard coded credentials stored on those resources.
ka3Ht0000000q6oIAA__eid=ka3Ht0000000q6o&feoid=00N2J00000APFDu&refid=0EMHt000005Ns2j.png
Figure 4: Table-Stakes Concepts Visualized

Success Stories
These three success stories below showcase how organizations, with varying degrees of PAM implementation and identity security expertise, were able to leverage the Blueprint's guidance to prioritize their efforts, make meaningful progress and ultimately build successful identity security programs.


At the Starting Line
This organization had no PAM solution in place and limited resources and identity security expertise. They lacked an implementation strategy and forward-thinking security plan. They assessed their environment to understand their risks, discussed internal priorities with their executive security leaders and ultimately leveraged the Blueprint to guide their roadmap creation. The focused on quick wins, allowing for a smooth introduction of PAM controls and built a 1-year program roadmap help eliminate uncertainty.


A Rough Start
This organization started their PAM journey off getting tripped up by complex, low-value use cases. Which created a lack of user buy-in and internal champions, and their program fluttered due to lack of value. They reprioritized using the guidance from the Blueprint and focused on quick wins, which helped show immediate ROI. This resulted in a boost of internal confidence and allowed for approval of expansion to additional technologies and systems and a multi-year identity security strategy plan.


Post-Breach
This organization had a relatively mature identity security program but experienced an identity-related attack. They wanted to ensure that security best practices are being followed moving forward and to reprioritize their existing roadmap based on new findings. They mitigated immediate risks identified via breach analysis and assessed remaining gaps by comparing against Blueprint. They reprioritized to close the gaps that could threaten the org’s mission or customers.

Next Steps for Improving Your Maturity
We hope this article provided you with some meaningful insight into what maturity means and how you can progress. To improve your organization's identity security maturity, it's essential to take a proactive approach to assessment and planning. To take your maturity to the next level, we recommend the following three actions: By utilizing the resources above, you can take a comprehensive approach to building a strong identity security plan and advancing your organization's maturity level.

Have a question about how others are maturing their identity security programs? Feel free to reach out to your peers in the Discussions here on the Community.
  • 1896 Views
  • 0 comments
  • 0 Likes
Top Liked Authors