NGFW PA820 9.1.4 Strange NAT issue

[MrFritz]

We have a simple basic setup:

WAN1/1 Untrust IP 123.45.67.89/29

LAN1/2 Trust IP 10.9.8.1/16

We NAT our WAN interface out to a different IP in the same network. 123.45.67.90

NAT POL  Trust to Untrust Int1/1 Any Any to 123.45.67.90  

Security Pol is Any Any 

I ping 8.8.8.8 from the LAN1/1 and it NATs out correctly with the .90 address

Devices behind the firewall are not getting NAT'd out, I have pcap that shows this.  The pcap does not show the NAT'd IP just the trust traffic from the device to the LAN1/1 on both outbound and inbound traffic.

 I can also ping the ISP GW from the downstream devices so I can get traffic beyond the FW but nothing beyond that.

[BPry]

@MrFritz 

Take a look at your NAT policy and double check that you actually have it configured correctly. Your traffic logs are also going to be a help here, as you can expose the NAT Source IP field to see what the firewall actually NAT'd traffic to. Weird NAT issues are almost always a result of your NAT rulebase entry not being correctly formatted. 

[MrFritz]

"rule1; index: 1" {
nat-type ipv4;
from Trust;
source 10.0.0.0/8 ;
to Untrust-ISP1;
to-interface ;
destination any;
service 0:any/any/any;
translate-to "src: 170.150.13.150 (dynamic-ip-and-port) (pool idx: 11)";
terminal no;
}

Security Policy

"rule1; index: 1" {
from Trust;
source any;
source-region none;
to Untrust-ISP1;
destination any;
destination-region none;
user any;
category any;
application/service 0:any/any/any/any;
action allow;
icmp-unreachable: no
terminal yes;

[reaper]

Can you check your default route? Since your zone is called untrusted-isp1, is there also an untrust-isp2?

Show routing fib virtual-router default | match 0.0.0.0

[MrFritz]

Untrust-ISP2 is not connected nor is the Zone created:

show routing fib virtual-router VR-1 | match 0.0.0.0
[?1h= 805 0.0.0.0/0 170.150.13.145 ug ethernet1/1 1500

[MrFritz]

ame: ethernet1/1, ID: 16
Operation mode: layer3
Virtual router VR-1
Interface MTU 1500
Interface IP address: 170.150.13.147/29
Interface management profile: no
Service configured: IKE
Zone: Untrust-ISP1, virtual system: vsys1
Adjust TCP MSS: no
Policing: no

[reaper]

everything looks ok...

if you start a ping out to the internet, can you check if the session ID of your outgoing ping to see which rules it hits etc:

show session all filter destination 1.1.1.1 application ping

show session id xxx

[MrFritz]

I can ping the internet from the Trust interface but nothing behind it.  My pcap shows ping from the trust interface NATs out correctly but the ping from a the devices behind the FW do not NAT at all.  Ping source 10.61.1.1 to host 8.8.8.8 success,   Ping source 10.61.1.2 host 8.8.8.8 fails....aged out.  Basically no NAT from devices behind the Trust interface.

[MrFritz · Accepted solution]

Strange I updated the OS 9.1.4 to 9.1.5 rebooted and now it is working